Daniel
Retired Administrator
He/any
18,846
55,118
Dell powers
|
Post by Daniel on Feb 14, 2019 0:00:38 GMT 1
The reviews are in!
Here's what the judges had to say about the entries for this week's Superstars Aligned Category!
|
|
Daniel
Retired Administrator
He/any
18,846
55,118
Dell powers
|
Post by Daniel on Feb 14, 2019 0:02:39 GMT 1
If I call your name, please step forward!
Mariah de la Storm
Yasmin Renshaw
Tea-Rex
Cand Ice
Coeur de Meme
You are all safe.
The Rest of you represent the Tops and the Bottoms of the week.
Now let's hear for the judges' critiques.
|
|
|
Post by Alper on Feb 14, 2019 19:22:30 GMT 1
Rebecca's Critiques Girls, this mess isn't what I signed up for. Amnesia Scanner Alex BG What happened to you miss Amnesia??? I thought you were back on track last week, but now I felt like I was wrong. Okay, I love Sia as an artist and yes, the song didn't miss the theme, although it felt really weak compared to the others. Hope you are not in danger love! | Ashley Nicolette Frangipane Alex UK AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA. You SNAPPED. I absolutely love this song choice. Charlotte OC is the icon herself, and "Blackout" snatched my ears and it fit perfectly to your zodiac sign! I love your consistency so far, keep it up! | Krampu$$y Julian Oh honey... I feel like it was just a bit too much... amazing! You served this week. Again, your song fit perfectly to your zodiac sign, and especially, the song itself, was spectacular. You have proven yourself that you are a fierce competitor, so I am sure that you have more masterpieces coming on the way! | MucLanna Josh Wow. I am sorry to say this, but this does nothing to me. I have been expecting a bang from you since the start of the season, but I think that the "bang" may be against your favor. This is probably one of the flattest entries of the season, and I am fearing that your time in here is limited. | Red Hot Chilli Lady Domas Same as MucLanna, the song did nothing to me. On the other hand, I didn't really get the message you were trying to give to us. I see the others explaining every bit of their lyrics, while I feel like the song you've chosen doesn't really associate to your sign. | Reth Rethnas I had faith in you, Reth. First off, MØ? Really? I don't really think you made a huge effort to find this song, which means that maybe you don't deserve to be here? Don't get me wrong, I think that you are a true competitor, although sending her with a pretty average song did absolutely nothing to me. Disappointed. |
| Stan Kan McCann William Ugh, finally a great song after the previous 3 catastrophic entries. I genuinely think that the song was fabulous! You were one of the queens that shined this week. I must say that I am not disappointed though, as you've been doing really great so far, that is my girl!!! Keep it up loves! |
|
|
|
|
Post by αndreas on Feb 14, 2019 19:34:58 GMT 1
Mullac's Critiques I wish that this week's song quality was inverted.
Amnesia Scanner Alex BG While the song isn't bad and it did fit the category, it just fell a bit flat compared to the rest of the songs. After your redemption last week I really hoped that you'd keep up, but unfortunately, you didn't. | Ashley Nicolette Fangipane Alex UK Another day, another slay! I loved your choice this week and I feel that it stood out overall! Great job and keep it up! | Krampu$$y Julian Just like Ashley, it's great to see another great entry from you! I don't have anything else to say so just keep slaying! | MucLanna Josh Girl... flat. It just didn't stand out at all and it was quite forgettable if you ask me. Yes, it fit the category but at the end of the day it's still Daniel's Song Race and not Daniel's Match-The-Theme Race so you're still expected to send a great song.
I'm disappointed. | Red Hot Chilli Lady Domas My dear, I fear that you represented your sign worse than all of your fellow competitors. While the rest tried to present an overview of their sign and show many aspects of it, you just sticked to one (negative) aspect of it, and as a Pisces myself, I didn't feel like it was enough. I did enjoy the song, but I expect more. | Reth Rethnas This was... okay I guess, but you can't win the crown by being just okay can you? Following your bottom placement last week I have to say that I expected more than MØ and this song... I truly hope that you'll redeem yourself next week, if you get to stay. |
| Stan Kan McCann William I think the critiques I gave to Ashley and Krampu$$y apply to you as well. I really liked your choice and you've proven once again that you're in it to win it. Great job! |
|
|
|
Eke
Technical Staff
they/them/any
6,635
30,736
but it's me who makes myself mad
|
Post by Eke on Feb 14, 2019 22:24:50 GMT 1
Kim Woodburn's Critiques sorry i don't have time this week </3 but just so y'all know this week sucked i don't have much positive to say x
|
|
Dylan
Moderator
he/him
12,344
29,252
Free Palestine🖤❤️🤍💚
|
Post by Dylan on Feb 15, 2019 0:43:06 GMT 1
Nene's critiques
Well ladies, with Valentine's day over, I can just say one thing:
However, the quality of songs this week made me wish I was celibate.
Amnesia Scanner (alex(a)bg )
Oh sweetheart, what happened this week? You were on track last week and I thought that this week you'd continue to snatch, but unfortunately you fell short of that. While I adore Sia, and that the song clearly sticks to the theme and specifically the sign assigned to you, the song was just rather flat and uninteresting to me. I'm not too worried about you however, because I know you are capable of delivering something much better my love.
Ashley Nicolette Fangipane (alexeh )
However the same can't be said for you my darling, because you brought it this week. This song definitely stood out among the others this week, and I have to say I'm very glad you went with this amazing artist as well hunny, she's a wig snatcher for me! Not only that, but I felt the song fit perfectly to your zodiac sign and that was also an important aspect, of course. Well done sweetie!
Krampu$$y (Julian )
Another amazing entry from you hunty! Not like I expected anything less from you, however given how abstract this challenge was, I have to say that you did an amazing job at representing your zodiac sign in this challenge. I've nothing more to say really, I'm just very excited for what you have to bring in the upcoming weeks! I'll be waiting.
MucLanna (Josh's Tattoo (Inactive) )
Hi hunni! To start off, I thought that your description on how you relate the song you found to your zodiac sign was great! You really knew how to fit to the theme this week and there's no doubt about that from the description. However, when it comes to your song, I felt it got lost in the pack this week. It's a nice attempt, but unfortunately when compared to the songs the other queens brought, it's just not working as well for me. However, I think that you can pull through by working harder, that's for sure.
Red Hot Chilli Lady (Dominykas )
Well there's a first time for everything as they say, and that's me critiquing you my dear. For me, your song was just too flat for this week, I'm afraid. I can't really say that I enjoyed it as much as the other songs and it just wasn't what I was hoping for, considering how well you've done so far. Also, may I also say I'm disappointed in your explanation as to why you chose the song? I can see an attempt, but it's just not focusing on the zodiac sign as a whole - you chose only to look at a specific, negative aspect, as Mullac pointed out, and compared to the other queens it just seems a bit... uninspiring to me.
Reth (~Rethnas~ )
Hunny, I was expecting much more from you this week. After an amazing first week, you planked in week 2 and after surviving that sing-off, I had high hopes for you to try turn it around for yourself. However, it turned out to be the opposite of that. While I do enjoy MØ's music, I don't feel like this song was a good choice for this challenge, and I feel like your attempt was kinda... rushed. I would have loved you to dig deeper, after all that's an important aspect when it comes to staying in the competition, and I've yet to see if you can actually pull that off.
Stan Kan McCann (ClassifiedCat )
Now here's a wig snatcher, at last! You went all out this week hunni, and it payed off clearly! An absolutely beautiful song and I can't say anything negative about it, although being realistic I didn't expect anything less from you given how you've performed so far. Like my fellow big boobed judges said, you are clearly in it to win it love, and I hope you keep it that way because I am living for it!
|
|